Articles: Sir John
Templeton
The Devout Donor
By Jessi Hempel
Business Week, November 28, 2005
John Templeton's $550 million gift doubles his funding of research aimed at showing that science and religion needn't be at odds
Sir John Marks Templeton has been a contrarian from the start. In 1939, when he still lived in a grungy Manhattan walkup
with mismatched furniture, Templeton borrowed $10,000 and used it to buy $100 worth of every stock valued at less than a
dollar on the New York exchange. The timing hardly seemed opportune: Hitler had just invaded Poland. But Templeton believed
that the impending world war would drive up the market -- and he was right. He went on to become one of Wall Street's most
successful celebrity stockpickers and then to pioneer the first global-investing mutual funds, ultimately selling his
Templeton family of funds to Franklin Resources for $913 million in 1992. His stake: about $440 million.
Now 92 and comfortably ensconced at a Bahamas estate, Templeton has recently made what may be his boldest move yet. Last
December he donated $550 million to his already existing private foundation, propelling himself to No. 11 on this year's list
of BusinessWeek's 50 Most Generous Philanthropists. His was no ordinary gift. While the vast majority of America's
philanthropic heavyweights choose to address traditional and tangible social needs -- feeding the hungry, curing the sick,
subsidizing the arts -- Templeton has something else in mind. He wants to make an impact on the world of ideas.
Templeton's controversial goal: to reconcile the worlds of science and religion. A devout man, Templeton began each morning
at his mutual fund group with a companywide prayer. Yet he is also a creature of Wall Street -- analytical, numbers-driven,
and skeptical. When he hears scientists quarrel with believers, he thinks both sides are missing the broader point. "What I'm
trying to do is say: 'Don't try to argue -- maybe you're both right,"' says the energetic billionaire, who still drives his
tan, four-door Kia Opirus two miles to his office five days a week.
What projects are being subsidized with the $60 million the John Templeton Foundation now hands out every year? It's a
unique mix of science and faith, traditional research and provocative speculation. One beneficiary is a Duke University
professor who is investigating the impact that regular church attendance has on blood pressure. Another is the Christian
liberal arts institution Calvin College, which puts on Templeton-sponsored seminars with titles such as "Evolutionary
Psychology and Scripture Scholarship: More Similar Than You Might Have Thought." The $1.5 million Templeton Prize for Progress
Toward Research or Discoveries about Spiritual Realities has been given to everyone from Mother Teresa to physicist Freeman J.
Dyson to Watergate-felon-turned-evangelist Charles W. Colson to evangelist Billy Graham.
Seeking A Dialogue
Templeton's venture is the most quixotic mission being undertaken by any major American philanthropist. He is, of course,
far from the only person in the country interested in reevaluating the relationship between religion and science. Social
conservatives are challenging orthodoxies such as Darwinism and the Big Bang while fighting for their right to control what is
taught to schoolchildren. Templeton has done much to cheer their hearts. The Association of American Medical Colleges, for
example, credits his foundation for the course in spirituality and medicine that has become a standard part of the curriculum
in more than two-thirds of the country's medical schools over the past decade.
But it would be a mistake to pigeonhole Templeton as a member of the Religious Right. While the foundation in the 1990s
backed supporters of the theory of intelligent design, the notion that God had a hand in creation, it has since distanced
itself from the idea. Foundation Vice-President Charles L. Harper says the group is the largest funder of projects challenging
intelligent design and notes that it has invited scientific critics such as Harvard chemist George M. Whitesides to speak at
conferences. "We're not trying to encourage people to jump on one side of the fence and throw mudballs at the other," says
Harper. "We're in favor of dialogue."
The Templeton Foundation is clearly walking a fine line, but it's one that feels comfortable to its founder. Templeton's
own faith stems from a Winchester (Tenn.) childhood in which his parents pushed Christian values of thrift and compassion. "I
grew up as a Presbyterian," he says. "Presbyterians thought the Methodists were wrong. The Catholics thought all Protestants
were wrong. The Jews thought the Christians were wrong. So what I'm financing is humility. I want people to realize that you
shouldn't think you know it all."
A visit to Templeton's boxlike home in the well-heeled Bahamian neighborhood of Lyford Cay makes it clear he is focused on
more than material things. Paint flakes off the antebellum pillars outside the Plantation-style residence. Inside, many of the
kitchen's original 1969 appliances grace formica countertops. French doors open from the living room onto a brick veranda,
offering views of a posh seaside golf club.
Templeton doesn't get to the nearby beach too much anymore. But he still has perfect posture, an affable grin, and the hint
of a gentleman's Southern drawl. A naturalized British citizen, he was knighted by the Queen of England in 1987 for his
charity. Yet at the tiny third-floor office of his foundation, he does his own photocopying and sometimes answers his own
phone. From the comfort of an office recliner upholstered in a print of butterflies, he reviews foundation proposals, flagging
promising philanthropic investments in faxes he sends daily to foundation headquarters in Conshohocken, Pa. On a recent Monday
he sent six.
Handing Over the Reins
The person on the receiving end of those faxes is usually Templeton's son, foundation President John Templeton Jr., a
former trauma surgeon and a born-again Christian. He has been on a hiring tear. In the wake of his father's enormous gift, he
must quickly figure out how to more than double the number of grants the foundation makes.
To see how the foundation operates, consider how it moved spirituality onto medical school curricula. In 1992, when Dr.
Christina Puchalski taught her first course on spirituality and healing at George Washington University, she knew of three
other medical schools offering such courses. In 1995 the Templeton Foundation began offering prizes (now $50,000 for medical
schools) to the programs that best integrate issues of spirituality and medicine into their offerings. A few years later the
foundation sponsored a conference where professors agreed on a standardized curriculum for a course that teaches medical
students about the role of clergy and helps them understand their patients' religious backgrounds.
The funding, paired with an official curriculum, has led about 90 of 125 medical schools to adopt similar programs. "When
educators can say I've got money, I've got this outside institution backing me up, they're much more likely to be met with
support," says Brownell Anderson, senior associate vice-president for medical education at the AAMC, who credits the Templeton
Foundation for the spike.
Simplistic vs. Sophisticated
Templeton has also lent credibility to research on the topic of forgiveness. The National Institutes of Health didn't fund
any projects related to the subject until 1999, when it backed Virginia Commonwealth University psychology professor Everett
L. Worthington Jr.'s study Forgiveness, Humility, and Gratitude Among Recently Married Couples, which measured how an
education program on forgiveness and reconciliation affects newlywed couples. Worthington's project was also funded by the
Templeton Foundation. This year the NIH funded five projects relating to forgiveness. Worthington says that before 1997, when
the Templeton Foundation first began funding research on the subject, he could find only 50 studies even remotely related to
forgiveness. At last count the number of scientific-paper citations had climbed to nearly 4,500.
By increasing references to religious concepts in scientific journals and by moving religion into public discussion at
universities, Templeton has made it easier for closeted believers within the elite halls of the Ivy League to form
communities. Martin A. Nowak directs the Program for Evolutionary Dynamics at Harvard University, where he spends his time
trying to figure out why people have evolved to help each other if evolution simultaneously fosters competition. Nowak is also
a practicing Roman Catholic, a fact he has kept quiet at Harvard until recently. He says the climate is changing on his
campus. "As a scientist who believes, you feel you are completely in the minority and you should never talk about it," says
Nowak, who recently became an adviser to the Templeton Foundation. "It's nice to meet people with whom you can talk about a
more complete perspective of the world."
Critics worry that Templeton is buying the support of scientists who are desperate to win research dollars. Sean Carroll is
an assistant professor of physics at the University of Chicago. An outspoken atheist, he recently declined an invitation to
present at a Templeton conference at the University of California at Berkeley. He says that because funding for quantum
mechanics is hard to get, some of his colleagues are willing to take Templeton's research grants even if they don't support
his beliefs. The Templeton folks make it tempting, he says, because unlike other academic conferences, Templeton's confabs pay
presenters. Carroll says he would have received $2,000 to speak at the conference, a similar sum if he published his talk in
their anthology, and a chance at a $10,000 prize for scientists under 40. For an impoverished academic trying to scrape by,
that's alluring. Says Carroll: "That's money I could have used to, say, buy a car!"
Other atheists take a more neutral stance. In 2003, Harvard chemist Whitesides agreed to help the Templeton Foundation
organize a cosmology conference called "Biochemistry and Fine-Tuning." Whitesides says he was surprised by the extent to which
spirituality was downplayed at the conference. Says Whitesides: "There are simplistic views and then there are more
sophisticated views, and I think the Templeton Foundation embraces a sophisticated view."
The foundation will have new leadership soon, though. At the time he made his gift, Templeton announced that he'll step
down in January, leaving his son, a conservative philanthropist whose religious views are more traditional than his father's,
to chair the board. Templeton has designed a process to keep his grantmaking on track: Every five years independent analysts
will evaluate whether officers are making grants that match his intent. If they find his son is giving 9% of the grants to
other causes, John Jr. has one year to correct the problem. If not, he'll be fired along with his two top people. That's not
very forgiving, but it's one way to ensure that Templeton's unique vision lives on.
Refresh Button: Philanthropy Outside the Box
Robert Johnson
NY Times, July 31, 2005
At 92, Sir John Marks Templeton may seem an unlikely dispenser
of the maxim that life is short. But he is not talking about the number of
years that one has to draw breath. What he sees in short supply
is the time that
most people allot to accomplishing something worthwhile. “We
should try to waste very little time on fiction, or entertainment,
or television,” he said.
He has wasted little time in his life. He
started his career on Wall Street in 1937, when he was in his
early 20’s,
and went on to create the Templeton family of mutual funds. Sir
John sold the fund business, Templeton, Galbraith & Hansberger,
to the Franklin Group, now known as Franklin Resources, in 1992
for $913 million and is now a full-time philanthropist.
Sir John, a Tennessee native who graduated
from Yale and was a Rhodes Scholar, has remained an innovator.
His philanthropies
include the $1 million Templeton Prize, which recognizes “progress
toward research or discoveries about spiritual realities.” It
has been presented annually in London since 1973; the first recipient
was Mother Teresa of Calcutta. (Sir John became a naturalized
British citizen in 1968 and was knighted by Queen Elizabeth II
in 1987.)
The prize is one of more than a dozen programs run by the John
Templeton Foundation. Some encourage research into the benefits
of cooperation between science and religion. Others focus on
the nature of altruism or freedom. Among the research topics
the foundation has supported, for example, is the salutary effect
of forgiveness on offenders and victims alike. The foundation
gives away about $40 million a year.
Sir John says he continues to work enthusiastically
with seven colleagues in his office in Nassau, the Bahamas,
and he still
helps to manage the foundation, which is based in West Conshohocken,
Pa. “Such enthusiasm derives from humility to think that
humans have not researched or discovered even 1 percent about
what can be discovered about aspects of spiritual realities.”
Why not concentrate his philanthropy on urgent problems like
starvation and poverty?
“Always, humans have wanted to donate toward alleviation
of suffering,” he said, “but probably, such donations
can be over 10 times more cost effective if focused on ways to
prevent suffering.”
Twice a widower, with 12 grandchildren and
nine great-grandchildren, Sir John is well aware that his philanthropy
is unusual and may
not yield many tangible results in his lifetime. But, he said, “it
is the far-reaching thinker who breaks out of the traditional
mold.”
The World's Greatest Investors Sir John
Templeton
By Eleanor Laise
Abacus Consulting Services,
July 1, 2005
BORN ON THE EVE OF World War
I, Sir John Templeton was a Yale undergraduate during the Depression
and a Wall Street
rookie in the runup to World War II. He's seen his share of tough
times. That's why, when he told SmartMoney last year that "there
are fewer opportunities than I've ever seen in 91 years," we
sat up and took notice.
Templeton never had much trouble spotting opportunity.
He hunted down global bargains long before jet travel got off
the ground
and invested in U.S. companies at the start of World War II.
The most important lesson we can learn from Templeton is to go
against the grain. An über-contrarian, he didn't just bet
against the crowd — he liked to invest at "the point
of maximum pessimism." The results don't say much for the
crowd. An investor who put $10,000 in his flagship Templeton
Growth fund at its launch in 1954 would have nearly $7 million
today. His outlook remains negative. "Prices of almost all publicly
traded stocks are now too high in relation to probable long-term
earnings per share, especially in the U.S.A.," he recently
wrote in response to our questions. He advises investors to keep
no more than half of their portfolio in stocks. "Bond prices
also continue to be too high," he says, "especially
the prices of lower-quality bonds." That doesn't mean he's out of ideas. He's a fan
of market-neutral funds, which keep a roughly equal weighting
in long and short positions and let investors profit from the
wisdom of the manager. And as always, he sees value overseas.
Investors should "invest in a well-managed mutual fund focusing
on nations and industries where share prices are not so high," he
says. He likes the Matthews Asia-Pacific fund, which invests
more broadly across Asia than most of the funds that focus on
the region. Templeton's tip for bond investors: Focus on countries
that have both trade and budget surpluses. Russia and Canada
fit the bill.
Though Templeton has been putting his own
money in hedge funds, their explosive growth gives him qualms.
He argues that "very
few hedge funds will be able to cover their very high operating
costs. Because many hedge funds work with borrowed money, it
is quite possible that many will become bankrupt within the next
year or two and the liquidation of those bankrupt funds will
depress share prices."
Depressed share prices? That will mean it's
time to load up on stocks. As Templeton put it shortly before
the turn of the
millennium, "In this century or the next, it's still buy
low, sell high." Hedge funds and overheated markets aren't
the only issues troubling Templeton. When asked about his view
on the Social Security debate, he points out that Medicare's
excess obligations are a more pressing problem. Even so, "evidence
is increasing that eventually, the age at which Social Security
will begin to pay pensions will need to be advanced at least
as rapidly as the average annual increase in life expectancy," Templeton
says. "Competition," he adds, "is always a strong
force for better results and therefore assets of pension funds
are likely to prosper more if not controlled by governments but
are invested in 10 or more privately managed custody accounts
approved by a board selected by the government."
Templeton, of course, doesn't watch the mailbox
for pension checks. His foundation, which focuses on spiritual
and scientific
research, gives away about $40 million a year. Given his interest
in values and theology, we wondered if Templeton would weigh
in on socially responsible and faith-based investments. "It
seems wise to search for bargains among shares of companies whose
activities are rapidly growing because they are beneficial," Templeton
says, "more than trying to decide which are 'socially responsible'
or 'faith based.'"
Interview with Sir John
Templeton
by Eleanor Laise
SmartMoney, April 1, 2004
Sir John Speaks --- He bought low during the Depression, sold
high during the Internet boom and made more than a few good calls
in between; Sir John Templeton, dean of contrarians, tells us
where to invest now
Spend five minutes in Sir John Templeton's offices
and you'll learn a
lot about the legendary value investor. It's not the imposing
portrait,
the honorary degrees or even the certificate of knighthood. It's
the
books. Crisis Investing shares shelf space with Eat Right for
Your
Type. The Hand of God sits near Invest for Retirement and Natural
Capitalism. Several thick volumes occupy substantial real estate
on the
top shelf. An investing bible? No -- it's the 1991 edition of
the
London Central Yellow Pages.
A 1934 Yale graduate and Rhodes scholar, Templeton
has a voracious appetite for information. The small-town Tennessee
native became
known
as the Marco Polo of his Oxford class, thanks to a round-the-world
postgraduation jaunt. In his late 20s he opened his own
money-management firm and began to put international investing
on the
map. His flagship Templeton Growth fund has posted a 13.8 percent
annualized return over 50 years, well ahead of the Standard & Poor's
500's 11.1 percent.
Templeton's track record is full of prescient moves.
In 1978, when Ford
was near bankruptcy, he was a buyer. When everyone else piled
into tech
in 2000, he was a seller.
Though he now lives in Lyford Cay, a decidedly
well-heeled corner of
the Bahamas, Templeton maintains a surprisingly modest lifestyle.
He
tools around at the wheel of a Lincoln Town Car. Orchids and
bougainvillea upstage his whitewashed home. It's the ideal setting
for
a quiet retirement, but that's not Templeton's cup of tea. Since
Franklin Resources bought his funds in 1992 for $440 million,
he has
devoted most of his time to philanthropy. The John Templeton
Foundation
gives $40 million a year to projects that explore the intersection
of
science and religion. Templeton's longtime philanthropic efforts
earned
the naturalized British citizen a knighthood in 1987. In his
spare
time, he hunts for global bargains, and at 91, he's clearly as
curious
as ever. As SmartMoney sat down in his cluttered conference room,
it
was Templeton who fired off the first question: "Have you
written any
books I can read?" Well, no. But enough about us.
SmartMoney: How did a kid from rural Tennessee
become a pioneer of
global value investing?
John Templeton: In Tennessee I didn't meet anybody
who owned a share of
anything. At Yale there were hundreds of boys from wealthy families,
but not a single one who was investing outside one nation. I
thought
that was just not sensible. Surely they'd get better results
if they
searched everywhere rather than limiting their search to one
country.
Then I investigated the investment counsel profession and couldn't
find
any investment counselor who specialized in helping people invest
outside America. So I saw a wide-open opportunity.
Q: In 1939 you bought $100 worth of every New York
Stock Exchange listed stock that was trading under $1 per share.
There were
104 names,
and 37 were already in bankruptcy. Why did you do it?
John Templeton: I was sitting in my office at 30
Rockefeller Plaza in Manhattan when
the news came out that Hitler had invaded Poland. It was obvious
within
a few days that it was going to lead to the Second World War.
During
war, everything that was in surplus, and therefore unprofitable,
becomes scarce and profitable. Three years later I had a profit
on 100
out of the 104.
Q: What signs helped you see that the U.S. technology
bubble was about
to burst back in 2000?
John Templeton: If you want to have a better performance
than the crowd, you must do
things differently from the crowd. Four years ago the crowd was
piling
into tech stocks. The prices went sky-high. I sold my clients'
technology stocks, and sold a lot of them short. I have put these
philosophies into a simple statement: Help people. When people
are
desperately trying to sell, help them and buy. When people are
enthusiastically trying to buy, help them and sell.
Q: That's a good way to look at it.
John Templeton: That's mainly a joke.
Q: In 1992 you predicted that "the next
10 years will be the happiest
period, and the most progressive," with "rapidly
increasing prosperity
for both Europe and America." Are you as optimistic about
the next
decade?
John Templeton: Very few people realize how fortunate
we are to live in the most
glorious period in world history. There has been more progress
in
prosperity than in any previous century. The Dow Jones Industrial
Average never went above 100 until a century ago. Now it's up
to 10700,
a hundredfold increase in one century. Probably in the next century,
the increase will be equally great, if not greater. But I have
to say
that we are starting from an unusually high price for shares,
not just
in one industry, but in practically all industries and all nations.
Q: What is your view of current U.S. stock valuations?
John Templeton: Over the next five years, the chances
are about 50/50 that the stock
market will be lower. There is a risk that stock indexes will
go down
by over 30 percent or they'll go up 30 percent. Share prices
are
remarkably high right now. The Nasdaq Composite index is trading
at 36
times next year's earnings and 95 times last year's earnings.
That's
high. For most of my lifetime I found bargains one place or another
below 12 times earnings.
Q: How does this environment compare with the market
of 1972, when the
Dow regained its late '60s highs of around 1000 but didn't break
through that level again until 1982?
John Templeton: That was a period of stock market
optimism, which goes in cycles.
There are at least five of these cycles every century. The one
in those
years you mentioned was a normal cycle. This one seems to be
more
exaggerated. Prices in those years never went as high as they
are now.
Q: Are there any sectors in the U.S. that look cheap?
John Templeton: No. I wish there were, but I can't
find them. The answer is to play
safe. And playing safe means diversifying among nations, industries
and
types of securities. At present I don't think anybody should
have over
half their assets in common stock.
Q: And you believe that no one should have more
than 50 percent of his
or her portfolio in a single country?
John Templeton: Yes. And no more than 25 percent in one industry.
Q: Do you think there is a real estate bubble in the U.S.?
John Templeton: Yes. Real estate is very different
from the stock market because
it's so local and separate in terms of type. But in many locations
and
many types of real estate, prices are dangerously high right
now. And
in real estate it's easier to say what's dangerously high. You
just
look at what it costs to rebuild. Right here in the Bahamas,
I have
recently seen people pay four or five times for a house what
it would
cost to rebuild.
Q: Do U.S. bonds look more attractive than equities?
John Templeton: Compared to the cost of living
[measured by inflation], you can
still buy American bonds. But at present there are bonds of other
nations that seem safer. It's wise to invest in nations that
do not
have an unfavorable balance of trade or a government deficit.
Q: Which countries seem the safest?
John Templeton: There are not many. There are almost
200 nations on earth and about
150 different currencies, and most of them have problems even
greater
than America's. But Singapore, Hong Kong, South Korea, New Zealand,
Australia and Russia don't have big problems.
Q: A few years ago you were buying STRIPs, or Treasury
bonds with the
coupons cut off. Do you still like them?
John Templeton: I bought STRIPs because the yield
to maturity was about 10 percent
better than what you could get on Treasury bonds. But I found
I did
better by changing from U.S. Treasury STRIPs to STRIPs of nations
with
stronger currencies, like the ones we just talked about.
Q: Where do you think the U.S. dollar will go from here?
John Templeton: The chances of the U.S. dollar
going down in relation to the euro
are no more than 50/50. The euro has already gone up 47 percent
in the
last two years. But the yen is up only 25 percent. Japan has
put
hundreds of billions of dollars into buying American money. The
quantities are so great that that can't continue much longer.
Japanese
money is likely to go up in the future.
Q: Are you concerned about inflation?
John Templeton: Long term, because we have more
and more democracies in the world,
we're going to have more and more inflation. Politicians who
are
willing to spend too much are the ones who get reelected. Look
back at
history. Inflation has averaged about 2 percent a year. Probably,
it
will average somewhat more than that in the next century. But
from a
short-range standpoint, there does not yet seem to be a shortage
of
almost any product. Until there's a shortage, you're not likely
to see
higher prices.
Q: What do you see as the biggest threat to economic
recovery in the
U.S.?
John Templeton: We don't need an economic recovery
because we're already operating
at a very high level. The greatest threat to maintaining this
level of
economic activity is debt. There's never been a time when people
worldwide, and especially in America, had such a high proportion
of
debt. I think 20 percent of people who have mortgages on their
homes
are likely to lose them in foreclosures. When a home goes into
bankruptcy, it's sold at auction. That pushes the price down
and
affects the prices of other homes.
Q: Does the U.S. government's debt level worry you?
John Templeton: Oh, yes. There has never been any
government anywhere in the world
that has such a big deficit in the federal budget. And there's
never
been a nation in history that had such an adverse balance of
trade.
However, if you look at those debts and balance of trade as a
percentage of gross national product, they're bad, but not
unprecedented.
Q: What does that mean for investors?
John Templeton: It's one more reason why this is a dangerous
time to own stocks.
Q: Even foreign equities?
John Templeton: Yes. In my long history I could
always find some nation where people
were desperately trying to sell. Now I can't find a place where
people
are trying desperately to get out of equities.
Q: So what do you think about the rush to invest in China?
John Templeton: The cycles will be much wider and
more frequent in China because of
the lack of information. Having said that, if you're investing,
you
should put a fairly large part of your total assets in China
because
within as short a period as 30 years, China is likely to have
the
largest gross national product any nation has ever had.
Q: Is India as great an opportunity as China?
John Templeton: Yes. You could say almost the same
thing about India, except in
terms of speed. The improvement in India is wonderful but not
as fast.
But the Indian market is up more than 80 percent in 12 months.
That's a
danger signal. It means you're going to take a lot of risk that
you
wouldn't have taken a year before.
Q: What's the world's best stock market now?
John Templeton: The best answer is none. There
are so many securities analysts
working on that question that the prices in different markets
are less
out of line than normal.
Q: So an influx of information has made life difficult
for global value
investors?
John Templeton: When I became an investment counselor,
there were only 17 security
analysts on earth. Now, in America alone, there are more than
32,000,
and they do have an effect on prices by doing research on where
to find
bargains.
Q: If you were starting out in the investing world
today, what would
you do?
John Templeton: Play safe. If you don't have your
money in equities, it's very
difficult to find a place to put it. Gold has already gone up.
. . .
People also tend to think it's safe to put your money in the
bank. When
I was studying in the U.K., people swore that it was safe to
put your
money in pounds sterling. But within a few years, sterling went
down
from $5 a pound to $1.50 a pound because of the war. If gold
and bank
accounts are no longer safe, where can you put it? Diversify.
Don't put
too much in any one thing.
Q: What have you been buying lately?
John Templeton: I believe there are fewer opportunities
than I've ever seen in 91
years. In the last year I've been using market-neutral hedge
funds,
whose policy is to have always the same quantity of longs and
shorts. I
have invested lately in two funds that are managed by people
who worked
for me when I was in the investment business: Jane Siebels-Kilnes'
Siebels Multi-Fund and Mark Holowesko's Holowesko Global fund.
They
aren't registered with the SEC, however, so American stockbrokers
can't
sell them.
Q: After the corporate scandals of recent years,
how can we restore
trust in the markets?
John Templeton: The answer is comparison. When
you're worried about those scandals,
stop and think, what nation would you feel safer in? At what
time in
world history could you feel safer? I don't think you'll find
any time
when the degree of information, the degree of honesty, is higher
than
it is today.
Q: You don't think there's anything the government
should do to restore
trust?
John Templeton: Yes. Keep their hands off. It has
been proven over and over that the
best regulation is free competition. Those that are not doing
a good
job for the public get squeezed out. I can't think of any nation
where
the quantity of regulation is already not too high.
Q: A couple of days ago, Franklin Resources, the
firm that bought your
funds, was accused of participating in market-timing arrangements.
What's your take on the fund scandal?
John Templeton: Everything I've just said applies
double to that. Can you think of
any industry or any nation where there are fewer questionable
practices
than there are in American mutual funds? I can't. If all the
claims in
the news were added up, what would it cost a mutual fund owner?
One
cent.
Q: You've lived here in the Bahamas for 31 years . . .
John Templeton: Yes. I've found my results
for investment clients were far better
here than when I had my office in 30 Rockefeller Plaza. When
you're in
Manhattan, it's much more difficult to go opposite to the crowd.
The
Greatest Investors - John Templeton
Investopedia.com
Born: Winchester, Tennessee
in 1912
Employer: Founder of the Templeton Group
Most Famous For: Created some of the world's largest
and most successful global investment funds using his independent
investment
strategy.
Less Celebrated For: More recently, his funds
have failed to provide the astounding gains his followers were
used to, partly
due to the recent Asian recession.
Quote: "The time of maximum pessimism is the best time to
buy and the time of maximum optimism is the best time to sell." Background:
Templeton is a true pioneer of the global mutual fund industry.
He has led the charge for teaching investors to
explore the
world for great investments. Investing overseas was virtually
unheard of until investors caught on to Templeton's strategy.
Today, the Templeton Group's combined assets exceed $25 billion.
Besides pioneering global investing, a great example of his
independent investment strategy occurred in 1939. With the outbreak
of war looming, a twentysomething Templeton bought every stock
selling for under $1 per share on the major exchanges. Within
four years, he had quadrupled his money.
Templeton is one of the strongest proponents
of diversification. He once stated that "the only investors
who shouldn't diversify are those who are right 100% of the
time."
Another one of Templeton's success stories is a man by the name
of Leroy Paslay. He was one of Templeton's earliest investors,
giving him $65,500 to invest in 1954. 40 years later, Paslay
was worth over $37 million.
After making billions through his innovative approach to investing,
he has now become one of the world's greatest philanthropists.
In 1987, he founded the $1/4 billion John Templeton Foundation.
Sir John
Templeton Reveals the Future of the Stock Market, Real Estate
and Life
Financial Intelligence Report
Recently, NewsMax and Financial Intelligence Report publisher
Christopher Ruddy visited with Sir John Templeton in Lyford
Cay in the Bahamas - the place Sir John has called home for
the past 32 years. His interview with Sir John follows:
At 92 years of age, Sir John Templeton
is one of the world's most successful investors, a legend
in his own time.
Money magazine calls him "arguably the greatest global
stock picker of the century."
Templeton's pioneering concept was to take
the old adage "buy
low, sell high"and apply it to global investing.
Templeton sought out the best opportunities anywhere
in the world he could find them. When he began investing globally
in the 1930s,
Templeton was truly a pioneer. Many Americans thought it unwise
to invest outside the United States and therefore forfeited a
world of opportunities. John Templeton's results, however, are
the stuff of legend.
When he sold his Templeton Funds in the early
1990s, they were worth an incredible $800 million. Templeton
personally walked
away with over $900 million.
Sir John's all-consuming goal was to never just
make money for himself, but to earn for others. As he told Philanthropy
magazine:
" At Yale I was investigating what talents God gave me, and where
I thought I could be most beneficial to people was to help them
make fewer stupid mistakes in selecting their investments." "At age 27, I formed my own investment
firm, working with just five wealthy people. Eventually, when
I sold out, we were
helping over a million people with some part of their investments.
And I felt that was a ministry, that I was doing a useful job,
that I was not wasting the life God gave me. But all during that
time, over 50 years, I felt that my benefit to people was not
as great as if I were trying to help them get spiritual wealth."
Sir John now works full-time as a philanthropist. His John Templeton
Foundation in Radnor, Pa., and his two offshore trusts have a
total of $800 million dedicated to philanthropy.
The foundation - run by his son Dr. John Templeton,
a retired medical doctor - is one of the few dedicated to discovering
how
religion can influence the physical world. Though he spends most
of his time on his philanthropy, Sir John remains dedicated to
his first vocation: the study of investments.
He cannot even utter the "R" word…retirement.
In fact, he has thought of writing a book called "Never
Retire." "I have observed in 92 years that the people who are most
diligent in working do live many years longer than those who
are lazy," Sir John says.
A few years back, he told me he was exercising
by walking against the ocean current every day for almost an
hour. Today he has
cut back his exercise, he says, to just 25 minutes a day.
He is not only physically active, but his mental
examinations of the market are sharp.
And his timing has been impeccable. He sold
short the dot-com and NASDAQ tech stocks at the very height
of the '90s boom,
making another small fortune.
During the past few years, Sir John has been
very concerned about the lack of quality investments available
in the
market, and
he has repeatedly warned of the possibility of a major
collapse in housing prices - and even a '30s-style run
on the stock
markets.
Here are some of Sir John Templeton's current
insights:
Do the Opposite of the Crowd
My job was being paid by wealthy families to
help them choose stocks and bonds. And my results were much
better when I
was working from here than from Manhattan, Radio
City and Rockefeller
Center. I had good results in New York. But when
I came here, I had better results. The secret, I think,
is
that
in order
to buy stocks at a bargain price, you have to do
the opposite of
the crowd. When you're going to the same meetings
with the other people in Manhattan, it's hard to be different.
Finding a Spiritual Way
About 12 years ago, I sold out. I had been helping
a few thousand wealthy families and I did a
lot of thinking
that
if I could
tell you the rest of my life, I might help
a few thousand wealthy families to become somewhat wealthier.
But
by selling out to
my strongest competitor [Franklin Resources],
I
can now devote 100% of my time to trying to help
people
grow
in a spiritual
way. And that's a wide-open field - very few
people who have any substantial amount of money contribute
to helping
people
grow spiritually.
The Study of Religion
We are tying to persuade people that no human
has yet grasped 1% of what can be known
about spiritual
realities.
So we
are encouraging people to start using the
same methods of science
that have been so productive in other areas,
in order to discover spiritual realities.
For example, to clarify, my grandfather
was a medical doctor. But he had never
heard
of a germ.
That
was only 140 years
ago. The medical doctors began to use
that as a science, and now
we know a thousand times as much about
your body as my grandfather new as a
medical doctor.
Or take the field of communications.
As recently as when Abraham Lincoln
was assassinated
only 140 years
ago,
nobody in Europe
heard about it for 17 days, because
communications was so inadequate. Now we have this enormous
communication system
around us all
the time. There's 1,000 times as much
communication as
there was 140 years ago.
Again, this is due to applying methods
of science to discover new modes
of communication. So
what my foundation
is focused
on more than anything else is to
encourage people to donate to scientific research
to
help discover
aspects
of spiritual
reality.
Managing My Own Money
I've spent 45 years inviting wealthy
families to pay me a fee to help
them pick the right
investments. We
didn't
have
any
salesmen, so it was a slow process
to grow.
But we got up to the stage where
we were helping with about
$23 billion worth
of other people's
money. Twelve
years
ago, I sold
that entire operation - including
this
building - to a strong competitor
in California called
Franklin Resources,
which
was on the NYSE. Now they're
helping with $88 billion in
assets.
I don't have any connection
with that forever. So my
main activity
now is
just managing
my own money.
Because
I think
I'm going
to do more good by using
my wealth to encourage others
to use scientific
methods
to find
the answers to
spiritual questions.
Finding Stock Bargains Never
More Difficult
I do think it's interesting
that in all my 92 years,
I've never
seen a
time when
it
was so
hard to find
a bargain.
I aided
wealthy families by helping
them find stocks that
were selling
at a small
fraction of what the
company was worth. But now, it's
very difficult
to find
companies where you
can buy
the stock
at a fraction of
its value.
In all my experience,
I don't remember a
time when
you
had to search so
diligently to find
anything
that was
a bargain. Bargain Stock Pick: KIA Is a Future GM
You
always find some
bargains, but just
less than usual.
The
last one I bought
for myself is a company
called Kia Motors.
I bought one of their automobiles and it gives me better value
than any other car I have ever owned.
They
are now growing better
than any other major
automobile company,
selling a great majority of cars outside South Korea in America
and Europe and so forth, but they manufacture them in India,
China and South Korea.
And
yet I bought that
stock recently at
less than five times
earnings. I think there's a chance - maybe not a probability,
but a chance - that KIA Motors will be larger than General Motors
30 years from now.
Assess
the Risks
In
judging the value
of the company, you
have to consider:
What is the risk
that somebody might
do something stupid?
I think
there's less risk in South Korea than there would be in China.
There are some stocks selling at bargain prices - but the risk
is greater.
Are
Any American Stocks
Undervalued?
I
haven't bought any
recently. I'd
like to. I just buy
where the bargains
are.
Another
Bargain in China
I
guess the second
one I would suggest
is something that
I invested in a few
months ago. It's
called Value Partners
and is managed
by a Chinese man in Hong Kong. It's a large organization - I
have about $100 million in it. It's about five times that big
all together.
They
specialize in finding
ways to buy stocks
that are not well
known in China and the region, and they invest in about 100 different
companies in that area. They invest mainly in things I've never
heard of.
Problems
with China
It's
difficult. The best
Chinese companies
don't have a public
market and are not listed in America. Those that are listed in
America are no longer cheap.
All
that's true. But
still, the rate of
growth is so strong
in China that I recently
guessed that within
a short period of
20
years, the gross national product of China will be larger than
America's.
With
four times the U.S.
population, that
is definitely achievable
within 20 years.
The
Dot-Com Crash and
the Crash of '29
In
1929, the Dow Jones
Industrial
went down to 1/9
of where it had been.
In this recent decline,
it only went down
30%. The
NASDAQ went down by 50%.
I
am worried about
exuberance. Like
you just said - you'd
like to have a house
at Lyford Cay, but
you have to pay four
times
what it costs to build. It's not the values - the prices are
high.
Will
There Be Another
Crash?
Yes,
but I've never been
able to tell
you when. If you
find a way, let me
know.
Well,
I wouldn't use the
word "crash." There will be
cycles. I do think economics has developed a lot since 1932,
so you shouldn't ever expect American prices to go down almost
90%, but I do believe there will be cycles where American prices
go down 50%.
Factors
Undermining the Market: American
Debt Is Highest Ever
American
debt is the highest
the nation's
ever had. The federal
deficit, the federal debt are the largest in history. But that's
just the beginning.
Also,
the unfavorable trade
balance is the largest
the nation's ever
had.
And
the national deficit
- the shortage of
taxes collected over
what's spent - is the largest in the nation's history.
Americans were famous
30 years ago for
being so thrifty.
They were saving
over 20 cents out
of every dollar
they earned. Last
year, Americans saved less than 2 cents on every dollar.
All
those things add
up to the fact that
there is almost sure
to be a period of pessimism - a bear market. Not a crash, but
a bear market.
The
old rule of thumb
for brokers was:
The bear is about
half as long as the
bull. If I had to
say when this bull
market started,
I would say 1990. So it's 14 years old.
The
immediate future
is that there are
more dangers than
I've ever known before.
It's just more dangerous.
More
Factors: The Weakening Dollar
and What Are Good
Currencies?
Let's
not use the word "good." Let's say "less
risky" currency. The less risky currencies are probably
South Korea, Singapore, India and New Zealand.
A
couple of years ago,
I bought Canadian
strip bonds.
I
haven't sold them
yet, but I've stopped
buying them, because
they are up 25% from when I first got them.
And
just within the last
week, I made what
is called a "straddle" -
I sold short $25 million worth of Japanese money and bought long
$25 million worth of South Korean money.
Why
Currencies Are In
Danger
The
psychology all over
the world
is that people
will not re-elect
leaders who want them to be thrifty. The voters will elect
the government
that spends more
money. And consequently,
all money
is risky. So I'm just taking the currency I think is especially
risky and putting it into one that's less of a gamble.
In
the United States,
President Bush was
the better of the
two choices. Offhand, I can't say that there's a single
nation where
you can depend on the voters to want to be thrifty.
There
is tremendous risk
in Russia. But inflation
is not a problem
in Russia so much
as it is elsewhere.
One
emerging country
is Singapore, which
doesn't have a real
democracy. So the
government can afford
to have
a
balanced
budget.
The
nation of Brazil
has share prices
that are quite low
in relation to earnings.
So I wouldn't rule
out
investing in Brazil.
Although
there's a lot of risk that goes with it, it always
pays to buy bargains. Brazil is at bargain prices. Bearish
on Gold
Gold
is too popular, and
prices have already
gone up. I remember
when a British pound
would buy an ounce
of gold.
There's
been a tremendous
inflation in gold
prices.
On Warren Buffett
I'm
a great admirer of
Warren Buffett.
But he has been
focused primarily
on U.S investments.
That is
strange.
To that extent,
I think he's short-sighted - or small-sighted.
Small-sighted,
I think. If he
had spent more
time in foreign
nations,
he would be better off.
Housing
Prices
Now
the U.S. has this
extraordinary
thing - I think
in some places
we see 50% to
100% gains
on the
housing market.
Other
places
across the country might be up 25% to 30%
in just a matter
of three to four
years. Incredible
gains.
When
you invest in stocks,
you get the same
value all over. The
same stock sells
at the
same value,
no matter
what
nation you're
in. But that's impossible in real estate.
Real estate value depends on locality.
If you're
going to be
a real estate
investor, focus
on location, location, location.
So
when you're trying
to invest in real
estate, you have to do a lot of serious
research
on whether this
location
is likely
to be popular in the long run.
That's
why I wound up believing
beachfront property
is a good investment.
I don't
think there's ever
going to
be any
more
beachfront than there is now. Now people
are getting bigger and the amount
of money is getting bigger. So beachfront
is pretty sure to go up in value.
Owning
a home on the ocean
is better than owning
one that's not on
the water.
But
there are large tracts
of oceanfront property
still available in
South
and Central America
in countries where there is
a rule of law. You used to be able
to buy land at very
low prices.
But
still there are some good deals.
A
50% drop off in prices
is quite possible.
I've
never, never ever
had a mortgage on
any house. I learned
that long
before you
were
born. When
I was a
child in Tennessee,
I watched so many people lose
their farms because they had
tiny mortgages,
but
they got to the
end of their
years, when
it was
impossible to earn a profit
on
the farm. They couldn't meet
their payments
and
their mortgage
was sold
at auction in
the courthouse.
I
don't rule out borrowing
money. But I think it's risky.
Positive
Mental Attitude
Positive
mental attitude helps
in every way.
It
helps
you
physically, mentally,
financially
- in
every
way. In fact,
I think you
ought to focus on that,
write articles
on it.
As
I said - when Abraham
Lincoln
was assassinated,
nobody in
Europe heard
about it for 17
days. So there were
more bad things
happening 140 years
ago than there are
now. But
today,
communication is so
enormous that
we're
flooded with
news and there's a
fault in human nature,
even with you. If you're
passing
a newsstand
and a stack of newspapers,
one of which
says 100,000 airplanes
landed safely
today and
one that says
one airplane crashed,
you'll buy the newspaper
that
says the one airplane
crashed.
Terrorism
warps your thinking.
It makes
people
think that
there are
a lot more
troubles
than there are.
But there
are less
troubles than ever,
and
we don't realize,
because we
read about
all the
problems.
Pharmaceutical
Stocks
I
think they will continue
to grow,
but they're
not cheap. They're
one of the
highest groups
of stock. Baby Boomers Retiring
This
is enormous.
But the adjustment
is so easy.
You just don't
start pensions until 10 years later. That solves it all.
It will happen.
Nation after
nation - not
only America,
but other
countries - will just have to declare that pensions are going
to start 10 years later.
I
think it's
inevitable.
I don't know
when, but within
the next 20
years, almost
every nation
will have to
change the
law to
say you can't get your pension as soon as you retire.
The
Coming Health
Crisis
I
don't have
answers to
everything.
I have thought
about your
big question
here. And I
think the answer
is to say that
no
health insurance should cover the total cost of insurance.
Health insurance
should cover maybe 2/3, but not all. That would give people
an incentive not to use health insurance excessively.
John
Templeton
From Wikipedia,
the free encyclopedia
John Marks
Templeton was
born on 29
November 1912,
in the town
of Winchester,
Tennessee.
He became a
naturalized
British citizen
and lives in
Nassau, Bahamas.
Business
Sir
John Marks
Templeton
is a highly
successful
pioneer
of globally
diversified
mutual
funds,
becoming
a billionaire.
He established:
- Templeton
Growth, Ltd.
(investment
fund) in 1954;
- the
John Templeton
Foundation;
- the
Templeton
Prize
for
Progress
Toward
Research
or
Discoveries
about
Spiritual
Realities
in
1972.
- the
Templeton
Library
in
Sewanee,
Tennessee.
Personal
He
attended
Yale University
and pledged
the Zeta
Psi Fraternity,
graduating
in 1934
as a top
scholar
in his
class.
He
was a Rhodes
Scholar
to Balliol
College,
University
of Oxford
from
which
he
graduated
with
a M.A.
degree
in law.
He
is a lifelong
member
of
the
Presbyterian
Church.
He
was
a
trustee
on
the
board
of
Princeton
Theological
Seminary,
the
largest
Presbyterian
seminary,
for
42
years
and
served
as
its
chair
for
12
years.
He
married
the former
Judith
Folk
in 1937
and
the couple
had
three
children — John,
Anne and
Christopher.
She died
in February,
1951.
He
married
Irene
Reynolds
Butler
in 1958.
She passed
away in
1993.
He
was knighted
by Queen
Elizabeth
II
in 1987
for his
philanthropic
efforts.
God's
Venture Capitalist
The strange
quest of
Sir John
Templeton.
By David
Plotz
Slate, Sunday,
June 8, 1997
Andrew
Carnegie's
libraries
embodied
the democratic
confidence
of the Gilded
Age. John
D. Rockefeller's
universities
enshrined
the scientific
meliorism
of the Progressive
Era. But
the defining
philanthropist
of our time
is not a
university
builder or
an art collector
or a chair
endower.
It is Sir
John Marks
Templeton,
religious
philanthropist,
investment
wizard, amateur
philosopher,
and full-bore
crank.
A do-gooder
for the end
of the millennium,
Templeton
pays professors
to promote
conservative
values, universities
to build
character,
and researchers
to investigate
the connections
between faith
and science.
He believes
he can reconcile
the irreconcilable
contradictions
of contemporary
society:
Christian
conservatism
and New Age
loopiness,
capitalist
greed and
sweet charity,
old-time
religion
and modern
technology.
Before he
started giving
away his
fortune,
Templeton
was one of
the world's
greatest
moneymakers.
A Yale graduate
and Rhodes
scholar,
he began
investing
in the early
'40s and
soon proved
a natural.
He established
the Templeton
mutual fund
in 1954.
He was the
first great
global investor,
buying international
equities
long before
other American
stock pickers
noticed them.
The Templeton
Fund grew
an astonishing
15 percent
a year between
1954 and
Templeton's
1992 retirement--a
$10,000 stake
in 1954 would
have grown
to more than
$3 million
by 1992.
Templeton
developed
a cult following:
Fund shareholders
thronged
to the annual
meetings
in Toronto
and obeyed
his every
pronouncement.
Even today,
five years
after retiring, |